Engineering, operations & design history
Individual port, university, walled-town and volcanic findings
Full repository source: docs/art-direction/towns-volcanic-native-20261103/review.md
Technical documentation includes historical decisions, proposals and verification reports. For playing instructions and practical rules, open Gameplay.
No matching entry. Try a shorter phrase or clear the search.
Individual port, university, walled-town and volcanic findings
All 25 complete native originals were individually inspected and matched to their current named PNG exports and pure exporter mappings, with independent decoder agreement. Historical export execution is not attested. Exact approved granite-ridge and old-oak benchmark evidence is reused from the earlier ruin review; their native hashes are rechecked and no fresh benchmark-view claim is made. Every canonical source approval and next action remains unchanged.
The Ash Plain category contains finite volcanic scenes with cones, vents and hot fissures. Its name does not permit repeating the full paintings as mesh ground or inventing eruption, damage, extraction or water rules. Native role/contact/scale/state and full runtime qualification remain separate from any future internal named-export reference disposition.
Two initial candidate IDs identify executed partial smoke studies. After selection, only Walled Town WOG-A-009268 is a newly registered native output; existing Basalt WOG-A-008355 is retained, and WOG-A-009269 has an explicit registered historical retirement disposition. Publication is pending. WOG-A-009268 changes 535 selected RGB samples. Original SHA-256 dc978b16667b95ccec5bb66c58f6c301d5225eabbc7adcdc5655bd0f6b63d715; study SHA-256 f9e213da4df2596b3b3eb7c769061cfa36a429210a20c2f6b1908bbc9a8c61d3. The 535 selected upper house-plume samples lose the pink tint on both backings. The lower smoke/wall/chimney-contact region stays unchanged; it and the water edge/silhouette remain separate gates. Original architecture, foliage and water detail remain exact. Lower smoke/wall/chimney contact, plume silhouette and purple/grey water alpha/chroma remain separate gates. Finite wall/town/shore role, physical scale/state, normal rendering, cost/lifecycle and admission remain open.
WOG-A-009269 changes 666 selected RGB samples. Original SHA-256 8144e1eeb41cc5750137c60ef129d8fd4605210b18a4b62090091dbbd419fc48; study SHA-256 3dba1a6da2d329573f563fc7d1302324948b9a6582d80ca8d18aa7951047350e. The 666 conservative upper-vent samples lose selected pink colour while the lower cream/orange heat glow, columns, crystals and lava remain exact. Residual pink tones and the speckled plume silhouette remain unqualified; this is a partial colour repair. Lower warm plume and genuine emission deliberately preserved. Speckled smoke silhouette, finite basalt/vent role, geological and crystal scale, terrain contact/state, normal rendering, full cost/lifecycle and admission remain open.
Four full-native light/dark browser comparisons preserve every alpha and outside-mask display pixel. All original architecture, foliage, lava, crystals, water and native dimensions remain. Basalt lower cream/orange heat glow is deliberately unchanged. Neither study is an approved complete replacement or world-ready source. No raw pixel dumps, duplicate previews or rollback baseline are created.
Evidence: preflight preflight.json, individual observations authored-observations.json, native repair validation native-repair-validation.json.
WOG-A-008147 / WOG-A-004406
The wide port scene has a rear blue-roof civic hall, right lighthouse and smaller round tower, red/blue-roof shops and market awnings. A foreground quay, wooden jetties, small sailboat, rowboat and crates remain finely painted; broad pale turquoise/green water bands surround the finite rocky apron.
Preserve all architecture, rigging, waves and native canvas. Qualify the actual finite port role, coastline/depth and quay/boat contact, water-band appearance, physical scale and state. Painted lighthouse, cargo, crane-free docks and boats grant no transport, trading or navigation mechanic. Native SHA-256 70681c047a245ab0815afd88d2c6dd983c60e6239f9d9ff3d4bbbea5a1936f7f.
WOG-A-008148 / WOG-A-004407
The tall portrait places a blue-roof lookout on a high rear cliff, a central red-roof clock hall and houses above a right lighthouse. Many steps reach a lower stone quay, detailed large sailboat and smaller rowboats. The outer right water ends in ragged blue/grey tips and a thin detached-looking lower trace.
Keep the complete portrait, fine stairs, rigging, water and rocks. Diagnose the water alpha boundary on native backings before any local correction. Qualify finite cliff/port geography, stair/quay continuity, ship scale, water contact and state without inventing a playable route or stock. Native SHA-256 1a7b9dc158f2ec4dea2c5a42969caab9563f286b67f7ae3392f8c464b5e436d3.
WOG-A-008149 / WOG-A-004408
A blue-roof clock hall crowns a tiered port town with a left cargo crane, right lighthouse, timber jetties, small boats and striped sails. Stone blockwork, trees, awnings, rigging and the enclosed foreground water remain crisp; the finite water apron has an irregular pale outer edge.
Retain the detailed original and native aspect. Qualify actual finite port/coastline geometry, crane/ship and building scale, dock/water contact and lifecycle state. Any outer-edge colour concern needs true-alpha diagnosis; painted cranes, sails and cargo do not establish transport or trade. Native SHA-256 a7a8c16fefe390d84e20a0b552860560fc86b8442e16487578b706570f5aada6.
WOG-A-008150 / WOG-A-004694
A large blue-domed scholarly-looking hall, left tower and armillary sphere overlook a fountain square, an open-book monument, a small round pavilion and timber houses. Fine roof tiles, stone stairs, lettering-like book marks and many trees remain complete.
Preserve native dome, gilding, book, foliage and paving. Qualify a truthful finite university/civic role, monument/building scale, entrances and terrain contact, projection and state before admission. Painted books, armillary and fountain do not add research, knowledge inventory or water production. Native SHA-256 e0cf98f1fba96a778bc84e526640a42c4f476d66daa2952f149a47a1a12dad5d.
WOG-A-008151 / WOG-A-004695
A large blue-domed hall stands left of a narrow stream and rear stone arch bridge. A right observatory carries a long brass telescope, while a small armillary sits in a foreground fountain. Roof tiles, ivy, benches, stairs, wildflowers and nearby houses retain fine native detail.
Keep the complete original and subtle foliage/water. Qualify finite campus/stream geography, bridge and bank continuity, telescope/building scale, entrance/ground contact and actual state. An observatory, fountain or book banner does not establish a playable research or water system. Native SHA-256 a80397ff852e91a10d6281099ed7de4b70350be0d6a76df0ca7096235c405844.
WOG-A-008152 / WOG-A-004696
The rear blue-domed hall and left book-banner tower rise above a central armillary square. A round right observatory has an open metal instrument enclosure; a front stone bridge crosses the stream beside a tiny timber dock and boat. Detailed trees, cliff surfaces and blue roofs remain complete.
Preserve the instrument framework, architecture, native river and foliage. Qualify the finite campus role, scale of instruments relative to buildings and boat, stream/bridge/dock contact, stair continuity and state without granting research, navigation or transport mechanics. Native SHA-256 23ec8ce632c9d41eac460f681725a5e56fb50f6a7e6443c60872dcdd875aa11e.
WOG-A-008153 / WOG-A-004697
A tall blue-domed hall topped by an armillary stands behind several narrow towers, a left timber building, right round observatory and lower book-lined hall. A front fountain and notice board border the central stair path. Thin pink-looking traces appear at some rear spire/roof boundaries.
Retain the full portrait, fine instrument rings, book spines, roof tiles and vegetation. Diagnose the narrow colour traces with native true-alpha backings before any masked correction; protect legitimate gilding and flowers. Qualify finite campus role, path/entrance contact, building/instrument scale and actual state. Native SHA-256 410507cf5fd8701a21bc1c2f81075d38b6e242fb430335801d65a154d0d22b62.
WOG-A-008154 / WOG-A-004698
A blue-domed hall crowns a stepped campus above a central statue fountain. A left telescope tower, right spired building and front book-sign hall surround small houses and a gate kiosk. Fine native masonry and trees remain complete; narrow warm/red traces follow parts of the outer dome, tower and terrain boundaries.
Preserve the artist detail, dome gilding, cloth and foliage. Diagnose edge colour and partial alpha separately before editing; do not globally remove warm colours. Qualify truthful finite campus/terrain role, terraces and entrance continuity, physical scale and lifecycle state; books and telescope remain painted scenery until bound to real rules. Native SHA-256 fe81b7116db001d9bd41e0d3b249df550c28821ee66036b4f2b7fd7f8922cd1f.
WOG-A-008155 / WOG-A-004719
A round crenellated wall and many cylindrical towers enclose a blue-roof civic hall, red/blue-roof houses, fountain, well and small stalls. The front closed double gate joins a detailed paved road. Masonry, windows, flags, grass and the outer rocky apron remain crisp and complete.
Retain native wall courses, flags, roofs and vegetation. Qualify the finite enclosed-town role, gate/road alignment, town/building/wall scale, terrain contact and state. Painted closed gates and towers do not grant passability, ownership, garrison or defense behavior. Native SHA-256 8d26f1e274716db5634f2e99d7881e0cf36cb9ebfcdd3119bbd53f7aa74bf71a.
WOG-A-008156 / WOG-A-004720
The enclosed town has a rear blue-roof clock hall and windmill, central striped market stalls and a front arched gate between round towers. Outside the right wall, a cottage and fenced wheat patch sit beside a stream, well and timber footbridge. Fine wall blocks, trees and water remain complete.
Keep the full detailed original, including legitimate yellow wheat and red roofs. Qualify the finite town/river footprint, wall and bridge contact, path/gate continuity, scale and lifecycle state. Painted mill, wheat, well and wall do not create production, food, water or defense rules. Native SHA-256 cdc504e5371601ffe90a26b72289fdfad51c7235e6228120c45e07a4d2dd46bf.
WOG-A-008157 / WOG-A-004721
A blue-roof hall, smaller houses, furnace-like chimney and central statue fountain sit inside a ring wall with a front gate. A small dock and boat occupy the lower-right water. The upper-left house smoke contains conspicuous pink colour, and the right water boundary has ragged purple/grey traces.
Preserve all architecture, foliage, dock, boat and native water. Diagnose smoke in its own bounded domain, protecting masonry and adjacent wall; review water chroma and alpha separately. Qualify actual finite town/wall/shore role, physical scale, gate/dock contact and state without inventing industry, transport or defenses. Native SHA-256 dc978b16667b95ccec5bb66c58f6c301d5225eabbc7adcdc5655bd0f6b63d715.
WOG-A-008158 / WOG-A-004722
The tall portrait features a very high timber-topped blue-roof hall inside a rounded wall with conical-roof towers. Many red/blue-roof houses, a small well and stepped paths lead to the front gate. Narrow bright red/pink traces occur on the upper tower roof, left battlements and parts of the exterior apron.
Preserve full portrait and fine building detail. Diagnose boundary colour on native light/dark true-alpha backings before isolated corrections, protecting intended red roofs and flowers. Qualify finite tower/town role, building/wall scale, path/gate and terrain contact, projection and state; no new passability or military system is implied. Native SHA-256 75ae75bd87cbe162be70311776d2ac08cf2a73a183ec3cf029c758fe481f7362.
WOG-A-008159 / WOG-A-004723
A broad ring wall encloses stepped red-roof houses, rear blue-roof hall and central clock building around a slender fountain. Round and square towers, blue flags, small stalls and a front gate remain finely painted. A short grey plume rises beside the rear hall chimney.
Retain native masonry, complete roofline, foliage and thin smoke. Qualify a truthful finite walled-settlement role, stair/gate/road connectivity, relative tower/building scale, terrain contact and actual state. Depicted enclosure and fountain do not add defense, navigation or water mechanics. Native SHA-256 9f9c09c2d670ef2a914221a804870e3152d84a8875ead794143f0a9d0c749beb.
WOG-A-008160 / WOG-A-003594
A broad dark volcano has a bright molten summit, a large grey plume and many orange branching lava streams. Yellow mineral-like deposits and several pale vents sit among crisp fractured rocks. One upper-left secondary plume has unusually hard white blocky breaks compared with the softer main plume.
Preserve dark rock relief, legitimate lava glow and yellow deposits. Diagnose the secondary plume alpha/shape separately on native backings; do not globally neutralize orange reflected heat. Qualify finite volcanic geography, lava and ground contact, plume scale/projection/state and complete rendering/lifecycle requirements; no active damage, eruption or resource rule follows from the painting. Native SHA-256 e7804cd5ff04760857c9645d0cdd11c6bec13cb5c30abebed4d398989dedf641.
WOG-A-008161 / WOG-A-003595
A left volcanic cone emits dark smoke above bright orange channels that descend across fractured basalt. A right open rock field contains yellow deposits, small pale vents and a tiny blue-green pool. A detached-looking pink mark appears above a far-right spire.
Keep the complete native cone, fine fractures, lava and pool. Diagnose the isolated right mark under true alpha before any targeted edit, distinguishing embers from residue. Qualify finite volcanic/pool geography, emission and ground contact, scale and state; depicted lava, sulfur-like deposits or pool do not establish hazards, extraction or water stocks. Native SHA-256 02f9433dbe4aee07bb83b47ab6920b0c59deede44c2b54684b688e67927b9c5a.
WOG-A-008162 / WOG-A-003596
The central cone sends orange lava into a stepped foreground basin beneath a right-drifting dark plume. White vents, yellow mineral-like outcrops, dead trees and angular dark spires retain fine native texture. The upper plume has a ragged wispy right edge rather than a clean hard silhouette.
Preserve reflected lava warmth, dark stone and legitimate smoke wisps. Qualify the finite volcanic basin, flow/ledge and vent contacts, plume scale, actual volcanic state and normal desktop/phone visibility. Any fringe concern requires native compositing diagnosis; a painted eruption does not add simulation events or damage. Native SHA-256 16df3ca1a3e86a3f7d47698d2be971596a5593bf1c849199e5874d77963e365b.
WOG-A-008163 / WOG-A-003597
A tall narrow cone has a bright central lava chute, thick grey/orange summit smoke, several lower vents and sharp dark ridges. Small conifers stand around the rocky base among yellow deposits; thin red/orange contours follow portions of the plume and rock edge.
Retain full portrait, intricate lava channels, fine trees and legitimate hot emission. Diagnose visible boundary colour separately from intended heat light; do not erase orange globally. Qualify cone/tree/vent scale, finite terrain contact and eruption/state suitability before source admission or world use. Native SHA-256 ba66a22a336344b4ffaf350bef137426b185f5aefafeba6d360a66ba49245628.
WOG-A-008164 / WOG-A-003598
A broad volcano rises above a circular foreground rock shelf around a central lava vent. Multiple orange channels, jagged spires, yellow deposits and disconnected small smoke puffs remain detailed; a tiny yellow airborne mark appears left of the main summit plume.
Preserve the painterly basalt, hot lava, deposits and plausible embers. Resolve plume silhouette and detached-mark identity without assuming every airborne pixel is a defect. Qualify finite volcanic geography, shelf/flow contacts, physical scale, static versus active state and full context/performance/lifecycle requirements; no new eruption behavior is implied. Native SHA-256 faa9f951fd050f8ec7d47679f7bb82ec8ba47e0eeb201284508e2ff6f1b4f420.
WOG-A-008165 / WOG-A-003629
Despite the Ash Plain name, this finite scene contains a large smoking lava cone, three smaller active vents, tall rock spires and a broad brown/grey ash apron. The two lateral vent plumes have conspicuous pink/pale upper portions against darker rock and transparent sky.
Preserve intricate ash/rock and legitimate orange thermal light. Reconcile the named category with the actual finite active-volcanic scene before any continuous-ground use; never tile the whole painting. Diagnose lateral smoke colour separately from heat reflection, then qualify vent contact, physical scale/state and full world/runtime requirements. Native SHA-256 258053e06e465204feb02803812dc0928da7e09cb683e11a8058d6ee68f4d0e8.
WOG-A-008166 / WOG-A-003630
A broad ash field extends right from an open lava cone, with thin orange fissures, small vents, dead trees and angular spires. One upper-right vent plume separates into rounded grey puffs and a detached speckled cloud. Native cracks, stones and bare ground remain detailed.
Keep the complete finite landscape and fine ash grain. Qualify truthful volcanic-ash terrain and active-state role, vent/smoke shape and contact, projection and scale. Detached smoke needs silhouette diagnosis; the named plain is not permission for repeating mesh use, resource extraction or hazard simulation. Native SHA-256 47841b524d27ee2388b5ab357eaea017b3a72f4658a118c3962d007335a57a78.
WOG-A-008167 / WOG-A-003631
A distant central cone feeds narrow orange streams through a barren ash plain with tall spires, dead trees and several round vents. A low rock escarpment crosses the front, where a grey water-like strip meets the finite apron. The summit smoke contains a faint pink/purple tint.
Preserve fine native cracks, trees, lava and the foreground strip. Determine its actual water/shore versus ash-shadow identity and finite geography before placement. Diagnose plume chroma separately from thermal glow; qualify physical scale/contact/state and full context without inventing water resources or eruption mechanics. Native SHA-256 366a4eba05dccdd5d2f990a68fc04bd431a4903177636f5883da8978e89e9c0c.
WOG-A-008168 / WOG-A-003632
The tall portrait has a rear lava cone and thick cream/grey smoke above a central orange fissure, smaller vents, dry spires and dead trees. Broad dusty patches partly soften portions of the lower ground; a left plume includes pink/grey lobes.
Retain native portrait, dust shading and fine rock/tree marks. Diagnose the left plume under native compositing before a bounded colour or silhouette decision. Qualify finite ash/volcanic geography, vent and ground contact, physical grain/scale and active-state role; no repeating ground, damage or extraction permission is granted by the category name. Native SHA-256 9040a63f227e2a4ca3ed732b1f3db14a5259b47895766d474816896b56279428.
WOG-A-008169 / WOG-A-003633
A rear volcano sends bright orange channels across an extensive cracked ash field with several small hot vents, barren trees, rock escarpments and a large central open crater. Multiple pale vent plumes retain wispy detail; all major subjects fit inside a finite rocky boundary.
Preserve detailed ash fractures, vent smoke, warm emission and dead branches. Qualify finite crater/plain geography, relative cone/crater/tree scale, flow/ground contact and actual volcanic state. Do not repeat the complete scene as a mesh background or infer mining, eruption, damage or water mechanics. Native SHA-256 8c464b6fcfaec6620bea051b6aabeb0ebb1a1a561ccf12cc17161917857c4270.
WOG-A-008170 / WOG-A-003664
A tall cluster of polygon-topped basalt columns has bright orange lava descending through its center and across a dark rocky apron. Several small glowing vents and pale smoke patches sit among finely cracked stones; blue-grey side shading retains the column depth.
Preserve natural polygonal column structure, surface cracks, legitimate cool shading and orange glow. Qualify finite geological formation, relative column scale, lava/ground and vent contact, biome/state and normal draw-size readability. Geological columns are a finite subject, not permission to repeat the full image as a ground mesh or add extraction/hazard rules. Native SHA-256 881821b95702cfc451093560dc8dde282791f1817315b4ae2ec5ccaba097faa9.
WOG-A-008171 / WOG-A-003665
The left tiered basalt stack has a recessed central basin and orange fissures leading to a right circular hot vent. Yellow crystal-like forms stand near the base. The right plume has conspicuous pink patches in its upper grey lobes and a speckled irregular top edge.
Keep every native column crack, lava channel and crystal shape. Diagnose upper-plume colour separately from the lower legitimate heat glow and smoke alpha. Qualify finite basalt/vent role, geological and crystal scale, terrain contact, projection/state and complete runtime gates; painted crystals do not grant a resource deposit. Native SHA-256 8144e1eeb41cc5750137c60ef129d8fd4605210b18a4b62090091dbbd419fc48.
Selected Basalt repair and explicit retired trial
The earlier retained WOG-A-008355 corrects 2,059 plume pixels while preserving every original alpha and green sample and the lower cream/orange heat glow. All 666 pixels in trial WOG-A-009269 fall within that existing corrected area, and the new partial leaves more pink. Prefer WOG-A-008355; retire only the unregistered redundant trial PNG and its preview after preservation checks. Keep every trial/source/output hash, the current native selected comparison, source and preferred final, all unresolved gates and an explicit registered historical ledger disposition for WOG-A-009269. The initial two-trial browser evidence remains an immutable record of executed work; only the Walled Town study is a new selected output. See selection and retirement basalt-selection-reconciliation.json.
Registration and retained gates
Catalog: 9,201 present files. Goal ledger: 9,225 records, including the explicitly retired private trial with an absent binary and retained successor. No original is unresolved as missing. Fifty-four present asset records and one historical record await publication. Initial review backlog: 111, frontier WOG-A-008172. Pending qualification records: 5,740. Every source approval and public runtime contract is preserved.
The wetland original has30 actually observed source frames across the calibration and focused repeat; the diagnostic has10. Twelve complete scenes were directly viewed and four full-PNG byte-exact prior views are reused for the replay. The original32-pixel Hex reload difference remains despite exact replay comparisons. No nonrepetition, complete physical grain/palette/contact, deterministic reload, performance or lifecycle approval is granted. Historical proof receipts remain immutable; current registration and working state supersede only their catalog-registration flags. See registration registration.json, selected native validation selected-native-validation.json and calibration evidence ../wetland-fine-grain-calibration-20261103/validation-summary.json.
Verified live release
Commit 8944fe8a707edb163d95da41307080c79defe0be deployed automatically through Railway and passed exact live verification: 9,201 catalog files, 75 native HTTP identities, 24 desktop/phone Atlas views and two gallery layouts. All 54 present-record findings and the separate retired-trial historical disposition are synchronized. The retained Basalt successor is exact and the retired private binary returns HTTP404. Existing source permissions, both hamlets, original artist bytes and /data saves are preserved. All complete artwork/context, wetland nonrepetition/palette/contact/reload and full performance/lifecycle gates remain open. The 31 next volcanic reviews and two new masked studies are prepared separately and are not included in this release.